020 3372 5125 Email us today
Enquire today

The team, headed by Dr Lusine Navasardyan, following Judicial Review proceedings, managed successfully obtained extension of Tier 1 (Entrepreneur) leave for an overseas business-person who had been refused extension of leave.

Background

The client, who had already spent three years in the UK establishing and developing a business, had applied for extension after the initial 3 years. Her application was refused, on the basis of what the Home Office considered to be lack of specified evidence.
Eligibility criteria for extension of Tier 1 (Entrepreneur) leave

An initial Tier 1 (Entrepreneur) visa is issued for 3 years and 4 months. It needs to be extended, if the Applicant wishes to continue residing in the UK and operating their business.
At the time of extension, the following requirements need to be met:

  • The Applicant has established or taken over a UK business (this means proving that the business exists and that it is registered in the UK, pays UK tax and has UK bank account)
  • Has invested the £200,000 (or £50,000 if on that route) in a UK business they are running
  • Has created at least 2 full-time jobs.

The above is basic listing of the requirements. All of the above are subject to very detailed and technical rules, in particular when it comes to evidencing these requirements. Tier 1 (Entrepreneur) whether at the stage of initial grant or extension, is one of the most difficult applications. The failure of nearly 50% of all cases makes the need to have the best immigration lawyers dealing with your case imperative. Most of the refusals in these applications happen due to the fact that the Applicants were not properly advised on the onset of their business venture of what the extension requirements are and how they need to behave to satisfy the same. Another major reason for refusals is not submitting the required specified evidence. This occurs, either due to the Applicants trying to apply by themselves, or not having legal advisers who are experts in the field. It is worth noting that due to specificity of Tier 1 (Entrepreneur) applications, you should seek advise from solicitors specialising in this route in particular, rather than generalist Immigration lawyers.

The Refusal and considerations for remedy  

In the present case, the client was refused because the Home Office considered that they failed to provide the specified evidence for job creation.
Normally, when an application is refused, the main issue to be considered is whether the refusal should be challenged or a fresh application should be made. In many cases, making a new application is a good choice. For instance, if the refusal is reasonable and correctly arrived at, challenging the refusal makes little sense. Making fresh application makes sense, in particular in situations where the first application was made on time. This is because of legal provisions that extend person’s leave until such time when their application is decided. This is known as 3C leave. Further to this, if a fresh application is made within 14 days after the refusal of the initial, in-time application, the Home Office will disregard the overstaying. Therefore, in all the cases where a fresh application will offer stronger chances of success, it should be the first option.
Challenging the refusal should only be considered for scenarios where the fresh application either cannot be brought (for instance where issues of overstaying would mean refusal on the general grounds) or when there is genuine error on the part of the Home Office and there is a risk that error will preserve in fresh application.
In our case, the client had provided all the evidence they held, there were minor defects in evidential material, that could, however be rectified had the Home Office applied the evidential flexibility policy. It was, therefore decided that in this particular case, challenging the decision was the right way to go

Routes to challenging a PBS refusal

Currently PBS (Points Based System) decisions do not carry a right of appeal. The remedy available for these types of applications is Administrative Review. This is a Review of the decision carried out at the Home Office by a senior caseworker. As the forum for the review is still within the Home Office, it does not take a leap of imagination to understand that very few Administrative Reviews actually succeed. The current rate is at 8%. However, despite the low chances of success, the Administrative Review still needs to be carried out and in a very careful and professional manner, as any further challenge is dependent on that.

In instances where the Administrative Review fails, further challenge will take form of Judicial Review. Judicial Review is, in essence, the blanket mechanism that keeps administrative acts under the control of Judiciary. Unlike the right of Appeal, it is not dependent on being granted by the Administrative body making the decision. A successful Judicial Review is contingent on strong Administrative Review, as otherwise it can be considered by the judges that should the grounds been formulated in a correct manner before the Respondent, the result would have been different.

In all cases, before proceeding to Judicial Review, a detailed merits consideration needs to be carried out, as Judicial Reviews can mean high costs for the clients and potentially also shouldering the burden of the opposing party, should the claim fail.

In the particular case of this client, strong grounds were prepared for her Administrative review and later on Judicial Review. Despite the fact that the Home Office refused the Administrative review, once the case reached the Judicial Review stage and the claim was served on them, they agreed to review the decision. This led to the client’s application being granted and our client recovered the legal costs for the Judicial Review procedure.

Follow-up support

Following the successful outcome of the Judicial Review, our client was advised on the future steps to ensure they would meet the Indefinite Leave to Remain requirements after completion of 5 years on Tier 1 (Entrepreneur) route. We currently actively work with the client to ensure their compliance.

If you require assistance with your application of Tier 1 (Entrepreenur), please contact us on 020 3870 2451 or complete our online form to make an appointment.

Please call us on 020 3372 5125 or get an online consultation




    Contact our experts in Paralegal
    Paralegal
    For legal advice
    call us today
    020 3372 5125
    Or complete our online enquiry form to make an appointment




      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      Dealing with Rakhi was more like having In house counsel than hiring a law firm
      So Rakhi Singal of RVS has just handled my divorce, it was a very complex case and I came to Rakhi at the very last minute on a friend’s recommendation. My case was a mess and I stood to lose everything.

      Dealing with Rakhi was more like having In-House counsel than hiring a law firm, she does not approach her clients as a cash machine like many law firms do, she works with you to manage and minimise your costs and de-escalate conflict rather than throw wood on the fire.

      She took a huge personal interest in my case, she was always available on the phone, very quick to respond to emails and is very honest and trustworthy.

      My ex had huge spending power and used a team of high profile solicitors against me, Rakhi literally saved me from complete ruin and helped me get a very fair deal with me spending 6 times less than my ex on legal fees.

      Thank you, my new family and I will be forever grateful!!!!
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      Rakhi’s passion for her profession supersedes the norm
      On dealing with a very stressful and emotional situation involving my young child. I was personally directed to Rakhi Singal. From the very outset of my situation, Rakhi identified the immediate difficulties I faced and offered me a sympathetic and rational approach to my situation, ensuring that she had a full understanding of my issues and concerns. Rakhi’s approach to my case was monumental and customary to my needs and that of my child, which was a fundamental point for me.

      The communication and support I received in and outside of court was nothing short of extraordinary. Rakhi’s passion for her profession supersedes the norm and is clearly demonstrated through her results.
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      Really impressed with Rakhi’s dedication to our case
      Could not be more pleased with the results!

      I approached RVS solicitors as they were highly recommended and now I completely understand why. Soon as I contacted Rakhi I knew I wanted to use her, she was so professional and easy to get along with. I was faced with clients who were refusing the pay invoices, Rakhi immediately reassured me that she was able to help me and recoup these costs. She dealt with the whole process very professionally.

      Really impressed with Rakhi’s dedication to our case and her knowledge and experience on dealing with the case. She communicated with us throughout the process, providing me with regular updates. Thank you so much, I cannot vouch for her work enough and RAW Invites are happy for you to continue to act for all their matters in the future.
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      Very detailed advice, friendly and approachable
      Excellent service for my wife's spousal visa from Lusine: very detailed advice, friendly and approachable. Also flexible in contact by email and provided an excellent cover letter.
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      She is professional, intelligent, hard worker and cheerful!
      I highly recommend Dr. Lusine Navasardyan, as she is professional, intelligent, hard worker and cheerful, she helped us from the beginning of our case until the very end, when she prepared a strong bundle with over 385 pages, which helped us get a successful victory in our Asylum case . I strongly recommend her as I really appreciate all the professional work that she has done . Many thanks to her.
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      She has been very professional and a reliable person
      Dr. Lusine has been working on my case. She has been very professional and a reliable person. She was always attending to my queries and she has always been very friendly throughout my case.
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      She is very professional while creating a friendly and comforting relationship with her clients
      I am very happy with the level and quality of service I got from Dr. Lusine Navasardyan. She is very professional while creating a friendly and comforting relationship with her clients. The service from Lusine was professional,efficient and well organised. Lusine worked extremely hard at resolving my all issues while getting the best result.
      Latest News