020 3372 5125 Email us today
Enquire today

The story of Edinburgh father, Jodie Smith, makes for harrowing reading.   Mr Smith met Thai national Jintra Jummaimuang while he was travelling in Thailand in 2006.  After she became pregnant four months later, they both decided to move back to Britain, where their son, Joleon, was born as a UK national.  The couple later married but separated when Joleon was two.  In November 2017, Ms Jummaimuang moved with 10-year-old Joleon to Thailand without the consent of Mr Smith.  Despite repeated efforts to contact his estranged ex-wife, Mr Smith, desperate to find his son, flew to Bangkok.  Tracking him down in a remote Thai village, he took the child without the knowledge of the mother.  He was promptly arrested at Bangkok airport for trespassing into his ex-wife’s home.  Mr Smith disputed that he had trespassed, stating only his son had entered the property to collect his passport.  According to media accounts, Mr Smith was placed in Sakon Nakhon Prison, 400 miles north of Bangkok near the Laos border, with Sean Fulton, founder of charity Abducted Angels, who had joined him on the journey.  It was believed Mr Smith was facing a five-year prison term, but both men were released after 43 days, having shared a cell with 50 other prisoners.  It is understood the release was in part driven by Jintra herself after she re-established communication with Mr Smith, in an effort to resolve the matter.

The case of Mr Smith highlights the complexities of an international child abduction case where one or both countries are not signatories to the Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction (the Hague Convention).  While Thailand has signed the Hague Convention, the UK has not entered into treaty relations with Thailand, meaning the Convention does not apply between the countries.

How the Hague Convention offers protection

Where two countries are signatories to the Hague Convention, parents left behind in cases of international child abduction can formally apply for the return of the abducted child to their place of habitual residence.  And in addition, if a child is taken from an EU country, ‘Brussels II bis’, a European Union Regulation specifically related to family law conflicts, means the case must be decided within six weeks of the application being lodged.  It is important to understand that Brussels II bis is not intended to conflict with the Hague Convention and aims to act to further deter international child abduction, and if abduction does occur, faster repatriation of the child to his or her country of habitual residence.  The Convention only applies to children up to the age of 16 years.

Establishing the child’s correct place of ‘habitual residence’ is crucial when seeking to have an abducted child returned as this determines the legal jurisdiction whereby Courts have the power to uphold parental responsibility.   The applicant must also demonstrate there has been a wrongful removal or retention of the child from their country of habitual residence, in breach of their rights of custody.

At present, there are 99 member states signed up to the Hague Convention, however many countries are not, including China, Malaysia, India, Saudi Arabia, and Iran.

Where a country is not a member of the Hague Convention, it may be a signatory to a bilateral judicial agreement with the UK, (Egypt is an example of one such country).  These agreements are designed to improve judicial co-operation between Britain and the signatory nation.  Therefore, if the country your child has been taken to is not a signatory to the Hague Convention, it is crucial to seek legal advice to establish whether a bilateral agreement exists.

International abduction where the Hague convention does not apply

Many countries, including China, Indonesia, and Guyana are not subject to the Hague Convention and lack legal provisions which guard against international parental abduction, To further complicate matters; some States do not assist in the form of legal aid or mediation to help resolve family disputes.

In cases of international abduction involving countries not bound by the Hague Convention or party to a bilateral agreement with the UK, the legal situation varies according to the specific country involved.  For example, the abduction of a child from the UK to Saudi Arabia is not a crime in Saudi Arabia unless there is a Saudi court order regarding custody of the child or travel restrictions.  Neither the British government nor the British embassy can force the Saudi authorities to return a child to the UK, meaning abduction cases can be difficult to resolve.  In Iran, Sharia Law applies; however, the country is understood to be open to accepting foreign judgments in such cases and will often cooperate with Interpol where appropriate.

Ultimately this means that if your child has been taken without your consent to remain in a non-Hague convention country, without expert guidance, you may be drawn into a complex and protracted legal battle to have them returned home.  Such challenges are indeed surmountable; a family Solicitor who specialises in international child abduction will help you determine the best course of action and where necessary seek to negotiate with the overseas authorities to have your child repatriated quickly and with the least amount of distress.

Don’t delay; take action

If you suspect your former partner is considering or is in the process of planning to take your son or daughter to another country to live without your permission, it is essential to seek expert advice immediately.  Charities such as Reunite can also provide useful information in any case of suspected international child abduction.  RVS Solicitors have a strong record in representing mothers and fathers in cases of international child abduction to countries not subject to a bilateral or multilateral agreement on repatriation of abducted children.  Time is of the essence; by acting early, we can assist you in preventing the abduction before your child has been taken from UK territory, or if they have, seek to secure their earliest possible return.

If you have any questions regarding the issues in this article, please call us on 020 3893 2547 or contact us online.

Please call us on 020 3372 5125 or get an online consultation




    For legal advice
    call us today
    020 3372 5125
    Or complete our online enquiry form to make an appointment




      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      Dealing with Rakhi was more like having In house counsel than hiring a law firm
      So Rakhi Singal of RVS has just handled my divorce, it was a very complex case and I came to Rakhi at the very last minute on a friend’s recommendation. My case was a mess and I stood to lose everything.

      Dealing with Rakhi was more like having In-House counsel than hiring a law firm, she does not approach her clients as a cash machine like many law firms do, she works with you to manage and minimise your costs and de-escalate conflict rather than throw wood on the fire.

      She took a huge personal interest in my case, she was always available on the phone, very quick to respond to emails and is very honest and trustworthy.

      My ex had huge spending power and used a team of high profile solicitors against me, Rakhi literally saved me from complete ruin and helped me get a very fair deal with me spending 6 times less than my ex on legal fees.

      Thank you, my new family and I will be forever grateful!!!!
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      Rakhi’s passion for her profession supersedes the norm
      On dealing with a very stressful and emotional situation involving my young child. I was personally directed to Rakhi Singal. From the very outset of my situation, Rakhi identified the immediate difficulties I faced and offered me a sympathetic and rational approach to my situation, ensuring that she had a full understanding of my issues and concerns. Rakhi’s approach to my case was monumental and customary to my needs and that of my child, which was a fundamental point for me.

      The communication and support I received in and outside of court was nothing short of extraordinary. Rakhi’s passion for her profession supersedes the norm and is clearly demonstrated through her results.
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      Really impressed with Rakhi’s dedication to our case
      Could not be more pleased with the results!

      I approached RVS solicitors as they were highly recommended and now I completely understand why. Soon as I contacted Rakhi I knew I wanted to use her, she was so professional and easy to get along with. I was faced with clients who were refusing the pay invoices, Rakhi immediately reassured me that she was able to help me and recoup these costs. She dealt with the whole process very professionally.

      Really impressed with Rakhi’s dedication to our case and her knowledge and experience on dealing with the case. She communicated with us throughout the process, providing me with regular updates. Thank you so much, I cannot vouch for her work enough and RAW Invites are happy for you to continue to act for all their matters in the future.
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      Very detailed advice, friendly and approachable
      Excellent service for my wife's spousal visa from Lusine: very detailed advice, friendly and approachable. Also flexible in contact by email and provided an excellent cover letter.
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      She is professional, intelligent, hard worker and cheerful!
      I highly recommend Dr. Lusine Navasardyan, as she is professional, intelligent, hard worker and cheerful, she helped us from the beginning of our case until the very end, when she prepared a strong bundle with over 385 pages, which helped us get a successful victory in our Asylum case . I strongly recommend her as I really appreciate all the professional work that she has done . Many thanks to her.
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      She has been very professional and a reliable person
      Dr. Lusine has been working on my case. She has been very professional and a reliable person. She was always attending to my queries and she has always been very friendly throughout my case.
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      She is very professional while creating a friendly and comforting relationship with her clients
      I am very happy with the level and quality of service I got from Dr. Lusine Navasardyan. She is very professional while creating a friendly and comforting relationship with her clients. The service from Lusine was professional,efficient and well organised. Lusine worked extremely hard at resolving my all issues while getting the best result.
      Latest News