020 3372 5125 Email us today
Enquire today
Divorce: A Blame Game To The End
Divorce: A Blame Game To The End

Divorce: A Blame Game To The End

After decades of lobbying from the Law Commission, the Bar Council, Resolution, senior family law judges, and most family law practitioners, the Government has announced that divorce in the UK is to be reformed.  The main change is that there will no longer be a need for one spouse to blame the other for the breakdown of the marriage.

At present, to start divorce proceedings immediately, one spouse must accuse the other of:

  • Adultery
  • Unreasonable behaviour
  • Desertion

After two years’ separation, one party can divorce the other if they consent.  Should they refuse, five years must pass before you can divorce your spouse whether they agree or not.

Once the reforms are passed, couples will only have to state that their marriage has ‘irretrievably broken down’.

The BBC states that this change brings forth the biggest reforms in divorce laws for 50 years.

Owens v Owens – the last straw

Although there have been many calls for divorce reform over the past half a century, it was the case of Tini Owens that put the nail in the coffin of fault-based divorce.

Mr and Mrs Owens had been married for 37 years and had built a prosperous life thanks to establishing a successful business which turned over around £5 million per year.

Mrs Owens, the Petitioner in the divorce, claimed the marriage was “loveless and argumentative”.  She had an affair in 2012, and in 2015 she moved out of the family home and filed for divorce.

Mr Owen’s contested the claim of ‘unreasonable behaviour’.  And unfortunately, Judge Robin Tolson QC, sitting in the High Court, agreed that the behaviour described by Mrs Owens did not amount to unreasonable behaviour.  He stated the farmer’s attitude was simply “old school”.

The judge went on to describe Mrs Owen’s allegations against her husband as “exaggerated” and “at best flimsy”, claiming they were “minor altercations of a kind to be expected in a marriage” and “an exercise in scraping the barrel”.  He also stated Mrs Owens was “more sensitive than most wives” and that she had “exaggerated the context and seriousness of the allegations to a significant degree”.

In a shock decision, the Court of Appeal upheld Judge Tolson QC’s decision, stating that being miserable in a marriage was not grounds for divorce in English law.  The court emphasised that if ‘unreasonable behaviour’ was contested, judges must apply the objective test in section 1(3) of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 to the subjective elements of the marriage to establish whether a petitioner could reasonably be expected to live with a respondent.  Mr Owen’s behaviour in the marriage did not, in the court’s opinion, was not unreasonable.

The Supreme Court, its hands tied by legislation, also upheld the decision.  Tini Owens must wait until 2020 before she can be free from her marriage.

A waiting game

So, the big question is – when will these reforms be enacted by Parliament?  The answer provided is when Parliamentary time allows.  One of the unfortunate consequences of Brexit is that ordinary government business must take a back seat.  However, given the media interest and the pressure from lawyers and groups to get the law changed, we may see the reforms enacted into law in late 2019 or early 2020.

Will divorce rates increase if no-fault divorce is introduced?

English divorce law is rather outdated when compared to other countries in the developed world, most of whom did away with fault-based divorce many years ago.  Scotland reformed its divorce laws in 1982.  It offers a simplified procedure whereby divorce can be applied for after one year’s separation (with the consent of the other spouse) or two years’ separation (no consent).  If a quicker divorce is required, there is a fault-based system available; however, in 2015 it was found only 6% of couples choose this route.  In England and Wales, 60% of those divorcing did so on the grounds of adultery or unreasonable behaviour.

There has never been any evidence that no-fault divorce increases divorce rates.  However, there are plenty of reports showing the distress and conflict which can arise through a fault-based divorce.

We will keep you updated as this matter progress.  In the meantime, if you have any questions regarding divorce, please contact us on 020 3372 5125 or contact us online.

Please call us on 020 3372 5125 or get an online consultation





    Contact our experts in Family department
    Divorce: A Blame Game To The End
    Family department - Solicitor
    For legal advice
    call us today
    020 3372 5125
    Or complete our online enquiry form to make an appointment





      Divorce: A Blame Game To The End
      Divorce: A Blame Game To The End
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      She is very professional while creating a friendly and comforting relationship with her clients
      I am very happy with the level and quality of service I got from Dr. Lusine Navasardyan. She is very professional while creating a friendly and comforting relationship with her clients. The service from Lusine was professional,efficient and well organised. Lusine worked extremely hard at resolving my all issues while getting the best result.
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      Dealing with Rakhi was more like having In house counsel than hiring a law firm
      So Rakhi Singal of RVS has just handled my divorce, it was a very complex case and I came to Rakhi at the very last minute on a friend’s recommendation. My case was a mess and I stood to lose everything.

      Dealing with Rakhi was more like having In-House counsel than hiring a law firm, she does not approach her clients as a cash machine like many law firms do, she works with you to manage and minimise your costs and de-escalate conflict rather than throw wood on the fire.

      She took a huge personal interest in my case, she was always available on the phone, very quick to respond to emails and is very honest and trustworthy.

      My ex had huge spending power and used a team of high profile solicitors against me, Rakhi literally saved me from complete ruin and helped me get a very fair deal with me spending 6 times less than my ex on legal fees.

      Thank you, my new family and I will be forever grateful!!!!
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      She has been very professional and a reliable person
      Dr. Lusine has been working on my case. She has been very professional and a reliable person. She was always attending to my queries and she has always been very friendly throughout my case.
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      Rakhi’s passion for her profession supersedes the norm
      On dealing with a very stressful and emotional situation involving my young child. I was personally directed to Rakhi Singal. From the very outset of my situation, Rakhi identified the immediate difficulties I faced and offered me a sympathetic and rational approach to my situation, ensuring that she had a full understanding of my issues and concerns. Rakhi’s approach to my case was monumental and customary to my needs and that of my child, which was a fundamental point for me.

      The communication and support I received in and outside of court was nothing short of extraordinary. Rakhi’s passion for her profession supersedes the norm and is clearly demonstrated through her results.
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      Very detailed advice, friendly and approachable
      Excellent service for my wife's spousal visa from Lusine: very detailed advice, friendly and approachable. Also flexible in contact by email and provided an excellent cover letter.
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      Really impressed with Rakhi’s dedication to our case
      Could not be more pleased with the results!

      I approached RVS solicitors as they were highly recommended and now I completely understand why. Soon as I contacted Rakhi I knew I wanted to use her, she was so professional and easy to get along with. I was faced with clients who were refusing the pay invoices, Rakhi immediately reassured me that she was able to help me and recoup these costs. She dealt with the whole process very professionally.

      Really impressed with Rakhi’s dedication to our case and her knowledge and experience on dealing with the case. She communicated with us throughout the process, providing me with regular updates. Thank you so much, I cannot vouch for her work enough and RAW Invites are happy for you to continue to act for all their matters in the future.
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      She is professional, intelligent, hard worker and cheerful!
      I highly recommend Dr. Lusine Navasardyan, as she is professional, intelligent, hard worker and cheerful, she helped us from the beginning of our case until the very end, when she prepared a strong bundle with over 385 pages, which helped us get a successful victory in our Asylum case . I strongly recommend her as I really appreciate all the professional work that she has done . Many thanks to her.
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
      Highly recommended. Lusine helped me out with my ILR 10-year continuous residency application. She explained everything to me, and patiently answered all my questions. She also put my mind at ease. They are very quick in replying to my emailed queries. I consulted two other solicitors before someone recommended RVS to me; the first one did not seem quite sure what to do, the second had exorbitant rates. RVS's fees are very reasonable given their professionalism. They give a breakdown of the fee and make sure you understand everything. They also make sure your data is protected; they use a secure upload site for your documents. I am very grateful to them and will definitely recommend them to anyone who needs an immigration solicitor. I would give them 10 stars here if I could.
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
      I am so thankful that we found RVS Solicitors. I had an extremely complicated immigration case which has been successful. Lusine and Eylem was extremely patient and helpful during the entire process and went above and beyond to help me. Their knowledge on immigration law is second to none and they explore all possible options in order to help you. I will never be able to thank them enough for their advice, service and compassion.
      What Our Clients
      Say About Us
      Testimonials
      Professionalism
      The best lawyers . They work very professional they help you they always out there for you to help you out in your situation well done RVS Solicitors I will extremely recommend 👍and special thank to Eylem Kara 🙂
      Latest News
      Divorce: A Blame Game To The End Divorce: A Blame Game To The End Divorce: A Blame Game To The End Divorce: A Blame Game To The End Divorce: A Blame Game To The End Divorce: A Blame Game To The End